How to Fight an HOA Violation in Maine

Maine's condominium fining process is governed by the association's declaration, bylaws, and rules, with the statutory framework provided by the Maine Condominium Act. Understanding both the statute and your specific governing documents is key to fighting a violation effectively. Compare Maine's rules to neighboring states: New Hampshire, Massachusetts.

The Typical Maine Fining Process

1. Violation Identification — The board or property manager identifies an alleged violation through inspection, complaint, or observation.
2. Written Violation Notice — The association sends written notice identifying the specific rule violated, describing the violation, and specifying the action required to cure.
3. Cure Period — Most governing documents provide a reasonable cure period (typically 10-30 days) to correct the violation before fines accrue.
4. Opportunity to Be Heard — Before imposing a fine, the board should provide notice of the hearing and an opportunity for the owner to present their case.
5. Board Determination — The board considers the owner's response and determines whether a violation occurred and what sanctions to impose.
6. Fine Imposition — If the board finds a violation that was not cured, it may impose a fine consistent with the governing documents' fine schedule.

Each step should be documented in writing. If the association skips steps or fails to follow its own procedures, the fine may be invalid. Maine courts expect associations to adhere to their governing documents and provide fair treatment to unit owners.

Follow this systematic approach to maximize your chances of winning your violation appeal or invalidating an unfair fine under Maine law.

Step 1: Review the Violation Notice

Within 24 hours, examine the notice carefully for:

• Specific description of the alleged violation
• Exact provision of the declaration, bylaws, or rules cited
• Action required to cure the violation
• Deadline for cure or response
• Notice of hearing date and your right to be heard
• The fine amount or schedule that may apply

Step 2: Review Your Governing Documents

Pull your declaration, bylaws, and rules. Under the Maine Condominium Act, the declaration and bylaws define the association's powers and enforcement authority. Verify:

• Does the cited rule actually exist?
• Was it properly adopted by the board?
• Does the board have authority to impose fines?
• What enforcement procedures must be followed?
• What is the fine schedule?

Step 3: Gather Evidence

• Timestamped photos of your property and the alleged violation
• Photos of other units with similar landscaping, parking, or maintenance violations not cited (selective enforcement)
• All correspondence with the HOA
• Records showing you cured the violation within the cure period
• Evidence of procedural failures

Read our guide on how to respond to HOA violation notices for additional strategies.

Step 4: Submit a Written Response

• Your factual defense with supporting evidence
• Procedural defects in the notice or process
• Evidence of selective enforcement
• Citations to the Maine Condominium Act and governing documents
• Clear request for dismissal or reversal

Step 5: Attend the Hearing

• Attend in person with organized evidence
• Present your case professionally
• Request documentation in board minutes
• Ask for a written determination

Step 6: Escalation Options

• Internal appeal — Check bylaws for appeal procedures
• Mediation — Maine encourages alternative dispute resolution; many courts offer mediation programs
• Maine Attorney General — The Consumer Protection Division handles some HOA complaints
• Small claims court — For disputes up to $6,000 in Maine Small Claims Court
• Superior Court or District Court — For larger disputes or breach of fiduciary duty claims

Selective enforcement is an effective defense in Maine HOA disputes. When the board enforces a rule against you while ignoring identical violations by others, the enforcement action may be invalid.

Why Selective Enforcement Matters Under Maine Law

Maine law expects condominium boards to act fairly and within their authority. Selective enforcement violates:

• The board's duty to enforce rules uniformly
• The implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing
• Due process principles requiring equal treatment
• The reasonableness standard applied by Maine courts

Maine courts have recognized that associations waive enforcement of rules they consistently fail to apply. If the board has knowingly allowed the same violation at other properties, it may be deemed to have waived the restriction.

How to Document Selective Enforcement

Step 1: Identify 3-5 other units with similar violations not cited:

• Landscaping — Similar conditions at other units
• Parking — Similar violations not enforced
• Architectural modifications — Unapproved changes elsewhere

Step 2: Request enforcement records from the association:

• Violations issued in the past 2-3 years
• Which resulted in fines vs. warnings
• Board minutes discussing enforcement
• Written enforcement policy

Step 3: Present comparative evidence:

1. Side-by-side photos of your property and unfined properties
2. Clear labels identifying each property
3. Statement of selective enforcement
4. Cite the board's duty of uniform enforcement
5. Request dismissal

The Waiver Defense

In Maine, consistent failure to enforce a rule can result in waiver:

• If the board has not enforced this rule for an extended period, it may have waived the right to enforce it now
• If many properties are in violation and the board has taken no action, selective enforcement against you is particularly suspect
• The board may need to provide general notice and a community-wide cure period before resuming enforcement after a period of non-enforcement